The prospect of funding an additional 150,000 further education places for young people and a legal guarantee of a job, may sound like a bold response to Britain’s growing NEET (Not in Education, Employment or Training) crisis. It demonstrates a welcome recognition that too many young people are being left behind. Yet while more training places may help some individuals, we should not confuse skills policy with economic policy.
The uncomfortable truth is that Britain does not suffer from a shortage of people seeking opportunities. It suffers from a shortage of productive, well-paid jobs being created in the first place.
For decades, governments of all political colours have responded to rising unemployment with a familiar formula: more training programmes, new qualifications and revised funding mechanisms. While these measures can improve employability, they do little if the jobs simply do not exist. Training people for employment opportunities that are not being created is like building a motorway that leads nowhere.
What Britain urgently needs is economic growth that creates real jobs and, crucially, ensures that the economic value generated remains within the UK economy.
Today, many government policies are unintentionally doing the opposite. Across construction, manufacturing and infrastructure, we increasingly import products, materials and systems that were once made here. The growing emphasis on offsite construction, often relies heavily on imported timber, steel and manufactured components rather than using raw materials that clay and aggregates that are readily available in the UK.
The result is a slow but persistent transfer of economic activity and employment overseas, added to which the new build housing sector is experiencing levels of demand that are worse than 2008. Viability and affordability have become a major issue with the Home Builders Federation reporting a £75,000 increase in the cost of constructing new homes since 2020. As a direct consequence home builders are closing offices and laying off staff, whilst manufacturing capacity is being closed, and skilled workers are losing their jobs. This only makes youth unemployment and new career opportunities worse and makes no sense, given the widely reported housing shortage.
The same challenge can be seen in the automotive sector. Britain was once a global leader in vehicle manufacturing. Today, the domestic market is increasingly dominated by imported products, whilst policymakers appear to have underestimated the pace at which international competitors, particularly from China, are capturing market share with lower cost alternatives that look suspiciously like cars designed in the UK. Unless action is taken, the UK risks becoming primarily a consumer economy rather than a productive one and our increasing dependency in imports makes us a hostage to fortune in an uncertain world where there is an urgent need to focus on resilience.
The arrival of artificial intelligence adds another serious dimension. Whilst AI will undoubtedly create opportunities and improve productivity, it also threatens to automate many roles currently undertaken by millions of workers. If policymakers fail to support sectors capable of generating large-scale employment, Britain could face levels of unemployment not seen for generations. This is already affecting graduates as White collar jobs are replaced by technology, but for the key trades such a bricklaying and plumbing, this is unlikely to be a serious threat for many years to come
This is why the focus on graduate or FE education alone risks missing the bigger picture which is driven by demand. The dream that we can somehow mandate jobs defies logic and is unfair to the young people seeking a pathway to a meaningful and rewarding career. Educators have a critical role to play in providing a learning experience which reflects the needs of employers, but opportunities will continue to be scarce if we fail to turn around our economy and consider carefully the long term social and economic impact of AI being used to replace jobs.
The construction industry and the UK building products sector should be at the heart of any long-term employment strategy. Together they have the potential to create hundreds of thousands of skilled jobs, support regional growth, attract investment and generate tax revenues. Unlike many service-sector activities, construction creates tangible assets, drives productivity and stimulates demand across a vast domestic supply chain.
Yet these industries are currently facing significant challenges. High energy costs continue to undermine the competitiveness of British manufacturing. Rising employment costs increase pressure on businesses already operating on tight margins. Policies that favour offshore manufacturing weaken domestic investment, while fragile consumer confidence suppresses demand for new housing and development.
If Britain genuinely wishes to tackle youth unemployment and the growing levels of economic inactivity among older workers, the answer is not simply to create more training places. The answer is to create the economic conditions that will result in more full-time skilled jobs.
That means supporting British manufacturing through procurement policy and advice, encouraging investment in domestic production, strengthening local supply chains, reducing barriers to growth and restoring confidence in housebuilding and infrastructure delivery. It means pursuing a genuine “Get Britain Building” strategy that places UK jobs, skills and economic value at its centre.
Young people do not want endless programmes. They want careers. Employers do not want subsidies. They want customers, demand and confidence to invest. Colleges and Universities can only train people for opportunities that exist.
Without growth, every new initiative becomes little more than a sticking plaster. With UK driven economic growth, employment follows naturally.
The solution to the NEET crisis and indeed the growing number of over 50’s out of work is not simply more education. It is creating an economy that once again generates the skilled, productive and sustainable jobs that Britain needs.
The West Midlands with its industrial heritage sits at the heart of this issue. One in eight young people under 25 are unemployed, many of whom have made hundreds of applications for jobs and are becoming increasing disillusioned.
The construction industry presents a once in a generation opportunity for the West Midlands to be a significant part of the solution to rising levels of unemployment. Not only do we need to build and retrofit thousands of homes we also have a plan to transform East Birmingham.
The East Birmingham Mayoral Development Corporation plans to deliver a £11billion investment developing the Knowledge Quarter, Smithfield, Sports Quarter, HS2 Curzon Street Station, Creative Quarter and Birmingham Central Heart.
This huge investment is expected to create more than 50,000 jobs and 20,000 new homes generating benefits that will reach across the east of the city where, in some places, child poverty exceeds 50% and around 27% of adults have never worked – more than double the national average.
A joined-up plan is urgently needed to ensure the region takes full advantage of this ambitious investment. This includes a presumption in favour for use of UK manufactured building products, the use of local contractors and importantly SME’s to build and the integral involvement of FE Colleges and Universities, working with employers to develop apprenticeships and other career pathways to ensure we have the skills we need to reimagine East Birmingham and beyond.
This is a personal blog post. Any opinions, findings, and conclusion or recommendations expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the view of the Centre for the New Midlands or any of our associated organisations/individuals.
ABOUT OUR AUTHOR:
Mike Leonard is CEO of Building Alliance CIC and also a Visiting Professor, Manufacturing and the Built Environment, Birmingham City University. He is the co-leader of the Centre for Future Homes at Birmingham City University & member of the Centre for the New Midlands’ Housing and Communities Leadership Board.
Mike is currently driving many initiatives to achieve our climate change objectives, whilst ensuring resilience in the built environment. A strong believer in the power of collaboration he has built an extensive industry and academic network, identifying, and acting on common goals.
He is the founder of the Futures Group, the UK cross-industry, and highly influential new homes “think tank”. Mike is currently involved in research aimed at improving the quality in building. This includes Future Homes Standard Demonstrators, preventing overheating, enhancing indoor air quality, addressing the fire risk, reducing the use of single life plastics, decarbonising the built environment, and embracing the skills gap.




